Saturday, October 5, 2013

Intimidating culture of numbers

THE running battle between drug traders all over the country and the government has dealt a severe jolt to continuity of medical treatment of a huge number of patient population in the country. The wholesale market and retail chains enforcing strike on Thursday in consequence of a mobile court action on Saturday speaks of a long drawn out row between the two sides.
We are appalled at the drug traders’ arbitrary and arrogant behaviour holding people to ransom. On the one hand, the troublemakers are selling spurious and even date-expired drugs, and on the other, they are shamelessly calling for strikes.
Instead of apologising to the people for having forced them to go without medicines they are demanding a license to sell spurious drugs. How dare they!
Two points are to be made here: One, the sheer number of drug dealers makes them feel clannish and even in genuine cases where action would have been due, they would have their association rally behind an unjust cause bandying about their trade union rights. This has happened with transport workers, or for that matter even any unorganised body unleashing mob power every now and then. This trend will have to be bucked or else we are in for a disaster.
The second pointer is towards the government agencies’ belated action allowing indulgence to drug rackets dealing in contraband medicines. That regular monitoring is of the essence cannot be lost on them.

Those Bengalis in West Pakistan

Our very own Shabnam spent long years in what used to be West Pakistan, making a huge impact on filmgoers in the province. Her Urdu, when she first decided to settle away from her Bengali ambience here in Bangladesh, was initially limited in terms of vocabulary and fluency. Of course, she had earlier made waves through her roles in Chanda and Talash, two Urdu movies produced in East Pakistan. But it did take her quite a while to master Urdu dialogues once she was in West Pakistan, where she was paired with the likes of Waheed Murad.
When you remember the more prominent among Bengali artistes who carved a niche for themselves in West Pakistan in the 1960s, you will be amazed at reliving the popularity they enjoyed among a wholly non-Bengali population. Besides Shabnam, there was Robin Ghosh, her husband and a man who created some of the most riveting film music in his times. There were Chanda and Talash, of course. And there were others as well, Chaahat for instance, in 1974. You might recall that absolutely romantic Mehdi Hasan number in the movie — pyaar bhare do sharmile nain / jin se mila mere dil ko chaen.
Shabnam and Robin Ghosh stayed on in Pakistan for a good number of years, until the 1980s when they chose to come back home. There is then the tale of Runa Laila, who went through the most formative phase of her life in Karachi per courtesy of her father’s work for the government. Laila remains a craze even now in Pakistan. Her foray into music, indeed into film songs, began with that most wonderful number picturised on the actress Deeba — un ki nazron se mohabbat ka jo paigham mila / dil ne samjha ke chhalakta hua ik jaam mila. Runa Laila came to Bangladesh in 1974, which was a time when all Bengalis stranded in Pakistan were coming back home.
The actor Rahman too spent a good few years in West Pakistan, where all too often he was paired with Shabnam in the movies. Together these two Bengalis proved again and again they could, besides enacting roles in movies in their own language, were eminently qualified to achieve a similar feat in Urdu movies. Rahman too returned home to Bangladesh in the 1970s. A powerful actor who survived physical inadequacies (he lost a leg in a road accident in the early 1960s), he died a few years ago.
If Robin Ghosh enthralled audiences in West Pakistan with his music, Muslehuddin did not fall behind. This extremely talented Bengali composed melody for such numbers as zindagi mein ek pal bhi chaen aaye na / iss jahan mein kaash koi dil lagaye na. Muslehuddin married the popular Pakistani playback singer Naheed Niazi, whose akasher oi miti miti tarar shathe koibo kotha remains an unforgettable song to this day. Naheed Niazi, closely related to General AAK Niazi, chose not to come to Bangladesh with her husband after the war because of public feeling here about a man who presided over the genocide of Bengalis in 1971. She lives in London. Muslehuddin died a good many years ago.

The week gone by

Amra Ka’Jan Shilpi Goshthi, a cultural organisation of Bogra, arranged a season-based cultural programme at Zila Parishad Auditorium in Bogra town on Monday evening. Prior to that, a short discussion was held, presided over by the president of the organisation, Abdus Samad Polash.
The discussants emphasised the key role of cultural activities in cutting across age-barriers and looking on the bright side of life. Culture was an important part of the ideology of the freedom struggle; the nurturing of culture can enable the country to march ahead, they added.
The discussion was followed by a refreshing presentation by the artistes of the organisation, enjoyed by a 100-strong audience.
————————-
Writers’ association Silver Jubilee
Meanwhile, Bogra Lekhok Chakro recently held its two-day Silver Jubilee programme with a turnout of hundreds of poets from different regions of the country at Woodburn Public Library in the town. The event was inaugurated by poet Mukid Haidar and poet and Joint Secretary to the Bangladesh government Aminul Islam, and presided over by the president of the organisation, Islam Rafiq. Secretary of the organisation Amir Khosru Selim delivered the welcome speech.
The inauguration programme was followed by a colourful rally in the town, children’s painting competition, recitation of poetry, discussion, honouring six personalities for their contribution in respective arenas.
————————-
“Shikhandi Katha” staged
Earlier in the week, Bangladesh Gram Theatre and Bangladesh Group Theatre Federation arranged a cultural exchange between Bogra and Noagaon districts by staging “Shikhandi Katha” at Zila Parishad Milanayatan on Saturday. The play was staged by Noagaon Coronation Hall Society, with the aim of eliminating gender discrimination and improving the theatre movement.
Before the play, a short discussion was held on the effective exchange of cultural activities.
The discussion was presided over by noted dramatist of the town Khandakar Golam Kader.
As part of the programmes, Bogra Theatre will stage the play “Court Marshal” — based on the Liberation War — at Coronation Hall Society Mancha of Noagaon town tomorrow.
Aminul Islam, Mymensingh
………………………………………………..
Around 700 puja mandaps will be set up in Mymensingh, up from 660 last year. As demand for idols for Durga Puja gathers momentum, artisans are working round the clock to complete the orders. They are also busy making idols for Vishwakarma Puja.
“The shortage of workers has thrown a damper on Puja preparations. We could not take more orders for this reason,” said Joyonta Ghosh, an idol artiste of the town. “As the price of materials used to make idols has increased several times in recent years, we cannot meet the monetary demands of workers,” added the young artiste.
Other leading artistes of the town like Shambhu Das, Sanjoy Das, and Ajoy Kar said that they work all year with a few interregnums and are happy with the increasing demand for idols. However, there is disinterest of the younger generation in the profession, and a shortfall of idol makers, he added.
————————-
Dance-drama staged
Elsewhere, dance drama “Mewa Chander Pala”, adapted from “Mahua”, a prominent chapter of “Mymensingh Geetika” enthralled the audience at a capacity filled Mymensingh Zila Shilpakala auditorium last Friday evening.
Sandipon Sangskritik Sangstha, a prominent cultural group of the district organised the event. The dance-drama was directed by Zohirul Haque Mithu.
Earlier, a discussion was held with Chairman of Mymensingh Sadar upazila parishad, Fayzur Rahman Fakir as the chief guest.
The speakers said, for the revival of our traditional culture and heritage, cultural troupes should be patronised by the government and the affluent section of society.

Celebrating Autumn in full fervour

With the drizzling rain and dark clouds floating in the grey sky, it was rather unusual for an autumnal morning. Though it was a bit less-saturated, Chhayanaut’s Sharat Utsab brought out the essence of autumn with their mellifluous renditions highlighting the nature of Sharat — the third season in the cycle of six. The programme took place at the premises of the Institute of Fine Arts, Dhaka University — better known as Charukala — on October 4 morning.
Adorned with the gentle and snowy Kash flowers and women in bright attires, the Bokul-tala was lively with the presence of audiences who thronged the place to sing together with the performers, sitting under the large tree. Along with the vibrant attires, multi-coloured umbrellas also covered the venue, even part of the stage; another uncommon scene at Bokul-tala.
Choral rendition of Tagore song “Dekho Dekho, Dekho Shuktara” in sync with a group dance, set the programme in motion, followed by another Tagore number “Shubhro Ashoney Biraj” by Sukanta Chakraborty. A number of songs — fitting perfectly to the mood — came one by one, insinuating into the audience; sometimes taking them down the memory lane.
“Kaar Banshi Nishibhorey Bajilo”, set on raga “Aashabori” and “Amolo Dhobolo Paa-e”, based on Raga “Behag”, explicitly articulated the feel-good gentleness of autumn atmosphere. “Sheuli Phool, Sheuli Phool,” “Tomra Ja Bolo Tai Bolo,” “Hey Khoniker Otithi” “Je Chhayare Dhorbo Bole”, “Ami Chanchalo Hey” “Amare Dak Dilo Ke” – all these tracks were sang for the celebration of nature, as well as life.
City dwellers, ignoring the rain and muddy streets set their feet on the premises to immerse in the melodies. Even though the weather was not perfect, the intensity of Tagore lyrics was capable enough to bring tranquillity at the premises.
The programme was a collective presentation of melody, lyrics and rhythms of Sharat, especially in the way Rabindranath felt it. Each and every solo and choral song spoke of the magnificence of the season of fragrant flowers – Sheuli, bokul, mallika, madhabi — and brought the audience a sense of calm and peace. Chhayanaut has been arranging Sharat Utsab since the 1960s. This year, Grameenphone joined hands with the cultural organisation to arrange the programme.

Invoking the Mother Goddess

Yesterday dawn resonated with the holy ulu and Shankho-dhwani coupled with the rhythms of dhak at Dhakeshwari National Temple in Dhaka. Marking Mahalaya, noted elocutionist Bhashwar Bandyopadhyay recited the immortal verses from the “Chandi” while several noted artistes performed devotional songs and dances at the event.Mahalaya ushers in the aura of Durga Puja. From the day of Mahalaya, the preparations for the Durga Puja reach the final stage. It is an auspicious occasion observed seven days before the Durga Puja, and heralds the advent of Durga, the goddess of supreme power. It’s an invitation to the mother goddess to descend on earth to ward off all evils. This is done through the chanting of mantras and singing devotional songs.Based on Raga “Bageshree”, noted singer Khairul Anam Shakil beautifully presented a Nazrul Sangeet “Ma-go Chinmoyi Roop Dhorey Aaye” at the event themed on “Dhormo Jaar Jaar, Utshab Shobar”. Aloke Kumar Sen performed a Bhairvi Sandra “Bhavani Dayani”. The artiste’s rendition seemingly touched the hearts of the audience as he emotively produced pukar with apt devotion.Accomplished vocalist Priyanka Gope offered a Mahalaya traditional song “Yea Chandi” while singer Bizon Chandra Mistry presented a devotional track from his latest album “Matir Protima”. Another devotional piece by promising singer Shimu Dey followed. Talented singer Sanjay Kabiraj performed a Nazrul Sangeet “Jago Jogomaya Jago Mrinmoyi”, set on Raga “Jogia”. Choreographed by renowned dancer Sharmila Bandyopadhyay, several artistes presented a group dance along with three solo pieces at the event.
Autumn is the season of softness and silkiness. The constantly-changing beauty of clouds; freshness and fragrance of sheuli-bokul; sunlight-glittering dewy pearl on the web of spider and the joyful advent of Devi Durga all are the features of the season. Music, themed on the season, has a nostalgic plea. A Tagore composition “Oi Bhubono Monomohini” reminds of the ushering in of “Durga”. The crux of the song focuses on getting rid of scarcity, poverty and dearth and bringing in food, wealth and energy. Another Tagore composition “Aaji Bangladesh-er Hridoy Hotey Kokhon Aponi, Tumi Ei Oporoop Roop-e Bahir Holey Janoni; Ogo Maa, Tomaye Dekhe Dekhe Aankhi Na Phirey, Tomar Duar Aaji Khule Gechhey Shonar Mondirey…” superbly depicts the season autumn and Devi Durga.

Deputy commissioners and national election

TRANSPARENCY International Bangladesh (TIB) has proposed that deputy commissioners (DC) should not be appointed as returning officers in the upcoming national election, taking into consideration the issue of “politicisation in administration.” It has also recommended that the Election Commission (EC) should employ its own officials in conducting the next parliamentary polls.
“District election officials, not DCs, should be employed as returning officers. We all know how politicised the government machinery has become … We cannot rely on the DCs,” TIB Trustee M. Hafizuddin Khan said at the launch of TIB research report in the capital recently.
The above observations are a scathing indictment on the unreliability of a significant part of the country’s public service. The DC is invariably a senior official belonging to the Bangladesh Civil Service (Administration) Cadre who is posted at the district level in a supervisory and coordinating post. Adequate care is supposed to be taken to ensure the merit and integrity of such holders of important public office.
Under the circumstances, it would indeed be very unfortunate if our citizens have to forsake their trust that is reposed in the exalted office of the DC. However, one can take issue with the TIB trustee’s observation that EC should be able to conduct the election with its own officials and that employees of a constitutional body like the EC are capable and trustworthy enough to conduct the election.
In needs to be pointed out that since mid-1990s constitutional appointees like High Court judges have proved to be dismally incapable in performing the onerous functions of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC). In fact, the caretaker controversy owes its origin to the bungled and mismanaged bye-election of Magura in mid-1990s when a CEC belonging to the higher judiciary failed to rise to the occasion for doing the needful despite overwhelming evidence on the field to warrant the postponement of a malpractice-laden election.
Readers may recollect the antics of Justice M.A. Aziz, another former CEC, who till date stands accused of preparing fake voter’s list and squandering crores of public money on procurement that could not be accounted for. The less said about former Judge Sadeque Ali, another election commissioner, the better.
The point to note is that the smooth holding of national and mayoral elections depends to a large extent on the unstinted assistance and cooperation of the regulatory outfits of general administration and the law enforcement machinery. District level principal officers of these outfits are generally senior officers belonging to the regularly constituted service cadre, and it is highly unlikely that they will extend ungrudging support to the election officers who are junior appointees.
If TIB’s proposal has to be acted upon by engaging those junior appointees as returning officers then imbalance and inconvenience are likely outcomes on account of seniority and the status syndrome prevalent in our bureaucratic culture. As of now, this reality cannot be lost sight of. While it is true that the last mayoral election at Chittagong was well managed by a capable lady officer belonging to the EC it has to be remembered that national election is a different ball game in which large-scale departure from existing practice will entail serious risk.
In a democratic state, the electoral process exercises determining power over those who hold political office. It is the electorate which confers the power to govern and calls government to account. The electoral system should be able to ensure a full franchise, and make sure that the value of each vote cast is equal to that of every other vote. It has to ensure that the conduct of election campaigns is regulated to ensure legality and fairness; and voting system is capable of producing both a legislative body representative of the electorate and a government with sufficient democratic support to be able to govern effectively.
We need to know that each aspect of the electoral process combines to form a system. Political bosses must not able to gerrymander constituencies so as to suit their own interests. Legal provisions would mean nothing if enforcement is left wholly in the hands of those who profit by breaking them.
In our situation, if DCs have been politicised, as alleged, then what is the guarantee that other segments of our public service including election officers have remained immune to the virus? Are we sure that election officials recruited during political governments did not receive political patronage? The moot point is, who has caused the so-called politicisation and how has it occurred? Would it not be proper to treat the malaise with a view to establishing a healthy polity?
Must we not gain by emphasising that the Civil Service owes its loyalty to the government of the day, irrespective of political party, and it is imperative that the Service avoids creating the impression of political bias. The anonymity and political neutrality of civil servants is reinforced by the rules restricting political activity. If the Civil Service is to serve governments of all political persuasions, it is imperative that civil servants, whatever their private political views, should not be seen to be politically active in a manner which would inevitably compromise their neutrality under one political party or another.
Divesting the DCs of their duties as returning officers on grounds of alleged politicisation would be untenably ludicrous because they will continue to perform multiple executive functions of developmental significance even after being branded unreliable for electoral assignments. Let there be a halt to the pernicious institution bashing. Let us treat the disease and not the symptoms.
It may not be incorrect to presume that the job of the EC pertaining to holding of election has largely been an executive assignment accompanied by quasi-judicial functions. Experiences in Bangladesh indicate that the EC has fared well under the stewardship of former executives. We still require well-rounded executives to adequately perform the onerous functions of returning officers in the national election.

Black Pepper

From a distance, the big, tall tree appears wrapped in a shimmering garland of yellow and green leaves covering the length and girth of its trunk. Coming closer, you notice that it is a vine that has climbed around the tree’s trunk, encircling it in a colourful envelope while digging roots into the flesh of the tree.The vine is piper nigrum, black pepper or gol morich, which is     consumed more than any other spice in the world.To grow a new black pepper vine, you cut a branch from a mature vine and sow it next to a grown tree. Within a year or two, it finds its foothold on the tree and starts climbing. After a few more years, the flowers appear,       dangling in strands from the climber. Around September, the fruits appear, tiny dots that soon grow into small pellets.In December, this fruit, still mostly green but plump, is collected. It is cooked for a few minutes in boiling water, until it turns dark, and then dried, giving us whole black pepper which, when crushed, add aroma and zing to food.The black pepper plant is a native of the Indian subcontinent, though today it is grown in many countries, notably Indonesia. It has been used as a spice for centuries and was sought after during ancient times. During the Roman Empire, the Arabs traded it by bringing it to Alexandria from where it was distributed throughout the empire. It was valuable enough for the Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius to impose customs duty on its import in 176 AD.In the middle ages, black pepper was an important ingredient in European food. Those who could afford to used it abundantly. Food quality, particularly that of meat, was often poor, and pepper helped disguise the otherwise foul taste. A recipe from the seventeenth century indicates the usage of peppers was about ten times what it is today for a sausage, for example.Of course it had arrived halfway around the world, and so black pepper was expensive. In fact, it became like hard currency, with some people  storing it under lock and key for their rainy day. When the Visigoths laid siege to Rome, their demands for  freeing the city included 2500 kg of gold, 15000 kg of silver and 2500 kg of black pepper!It was the most important spice for centuries, and it was pepper trade more than anything else that brought wealth to cities such as Venice, Genoa, Amsterdam and Lisbon.
The plant grows in many parts of Bangladesh, particularly in hilly    terrain. It usually climbs around a support tree and can grow up to 20-30 feet tall. Using plain stakes it can grow up to 8 or nine feet.White pepper also originates in the same plant; the only difference is that the fruit is ripened before being picked.If eaten raw, black pepper fruits taste mildly sweet – and, of course, peppery. Once cracked open, the aroma of black pepper fades quickly. Therefore,    connoisseurs usually grind their    pepper just before eating.

CJ recommends 10 HC judges

Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain has recommended to the president the regularisation of 10 additional High Court judges, appointed two years ago.Supreme Court and law ministry sources said the chief justice on Wednesday sent the law ministry the recommendation letter to forward it to the Bangabhaban through the Prime Minister’s Office.The law ministry is expected to forward the letter to the PMO tomorrow to place it to President Abdul Hamid for his consideration.Once the president regularises the additional judges, the law ministry will issue a gazette notification to that effect, and then the chief justice will administer them the oath of office as regular judges of the High Court Division of the Supreme Court.The process may complete within next week, before the SC goes on a three-week vacation for Durga Puja and Eid-ul-Azha, the sources added.In October 2011, late president Zillur Rahman appointed the additional HC judges for two years.The judges are Justice SH Md Nurul Huda Jaigirdar, Justice KM Kamrul Kader, Justice Md Mozibur Rahman Miah, Justice Mustafa Zaman Islam, Justice Mohammad Ullah, Justice Muhammad Khurshid Alam Sarkar, Justice AKM Shahidul Huq, Justice Shahidul Karim, Justice Md Jahangir Hossain and Justice Abu Taher Md Saifur Rahman.The HC now has 91 judges — 73 regular and 18 additional — while the Appellate Division of the SC nine. Of the existing HC judges, six have been dealing with war crimes cases at the International Crimes Tribunals.According to sources, the Awami League-led government has so far appointed 10 judges to the Appellate Division and 63 judges to the High Court Division of the SC.

Jatrabari woes end before Eid

After the long three-and-a-half years of sufferings that people underwent due to its construction work, the much-awaited Jatrabari flyover is set to open for public on October 11, official sources said.An official announcement of inaugurating the flyover on October 11 will soon come, and the prime minister is expected to open it, sources added.Over the years, city dwellers experienced horrendous traffic gridlock due to potholed roads along the flyover pathway stretching from Shanir Akhra through Jatrabari, Sayedabad, Tikatuli, Joykali Mondir, Kaptanbazar and Gulistan.“We suffer terribly as we have to remain stranded for hours in traffic jam every day,” said Nurul Islam, a regular commuter to Shanir Akhra from Farmgate.“Normally, it should not take more than an hour,” he added.Md Jasim Uddin, who commutes from north Jatrabari daily, said “Our sufferings appear to be over as its construction work is nearing the end and the main flyover will be inaugurated soon.”The air and noise pollution, caused by the construction work, had been like a hell for locals, said Delwar Hossain, a worker of a restaurant at Jatrabari intersection.During a visit to the site last week, this correspondent found that workers at Jatrabari, Sayedabad, Kaptanbazar, Tikatuli, Hatkhola and Fulbaria points were busy to get the flyover and its ramps ready for inauguration.Locals, however, said the separator walls, which were erected all along the central portion of the existing road, occupied ten to fifteen feet areas to guard the flyover pillars.These walls would obstruct the movement of people, they added.Md Sabuj, a local trader and also a resident of Wari, said, “Now we have to negotiate a one-kilometre detour at Joykali Mondir with to go to Tikatuli due to the pillar guards.”Mostafizur Rahman, a traffic police constable, said it seemed unwise to occupy such a valuable space of the existing road with guard walls. The space could at least be used for car parking.Md Ashiqur Rahman, project director of the flyover, said the separator walls were a part of the design to save the heads of piers on which the flyover carriageway rested against any possible collision of vehicles.There would be landscaping on the space enclosed with the guard walls, he said, adding that it was not a reasonable idea to park cars in the middle of the road.Salman Obaidul Karim, managing director of the concessionaire Belhasa Accom and Associates Ltd, said the pier guard walls had nothing to do with the beautification or inauguration of the flyover.However, Prof Md Shamsul Haq, who teaches civil engineering at Buet, said the pier heads were supposed to be above headroom and be saved by design.Only the pillars should be protected with the minimum of median to ensure maximum width of the existing road, added Haq, who is also involved as technical expert on various communications projects.Project officials said the up and down-ramps at Shanir Akhra and Chankharpool and one up-ramp at Motijheel along with the main flyover would be ready for inauguration.But the up and down-ramps at Janapath, Sayedabad and Dhaka-Mawa road would take four more months to complete as those sites were still occupied illegally, they added.Earlier, the government had set several deadlines for the flyover’s inauguration ahead of time and deferred those in each case.The construction work was delayed time and again due to the presence of underground and overhead cable lines of utility services along the project’s pathway.Such delay further increased the public suffering.The Tk 2300 crore flyover, country’s first ever Public Private Partnership scheme, is being constructed on Build Own Operate Transfer basis.The concessionaire is to hand it over to the government after 24 years of concession period.

BSF picks up Bangladeshi farmer

Indian Border Security Force (BSF) yesterday picked up a Bangladeshi farmer from Ratnai border in Baliadangi upazila of Thakurgaon while he was cutting grass along the border.
The detainee was identified as Khabiruddin, 32, son of Khoka Mahmud of Morolpara village of the upazila.Bangladesh Border Guard sources said members of Natoyatuli BSF camp picked up Khobiruddin.BGB sent a protest letter to its Indian counterpart and asked for a flag meeting to return Khobiruddin.

M N Nandy: Larger than life hero

Vast unpredictable rivers in Bengal have destroyed the glorious deeds of men, their livelihoods, their towns and threatened their very existence; they continue to do so today.  The Nandy family, once residents of Faridpore, were forced by the raging waters of a rogue river to leave their homestead and they went to settle on the other shore.  After a time Mathura Nath Nandy, along with a few close relatives, came to settle in the village of Kushtia, P.S. Ghior, Manikganj town, in the district of Dhaka.  He married Priyotama Dhar in the beginning of the 20th century.  They went on to have seven daughters and three sons.  The eldest son was named Manmatha Nath and given the ‘daknam’ (pet name) – Montu.  The Nandy house still stands in Kushtia.
Mathura Nath Nandy finished his FA examination financially assisted by his elder brother.  He intended to join a law course, but financial pressures made this impossible and he chose to join the Police Service.  He took early retirement in the late 1930s and settled down as a farmer in Kushtia. His wife Priyotama, a devoted mother, had received no formal education but was an ardent reader of Bengali literature and was a subscriber to Prabasi.  She took great interest in her children’s upbringing.  The ten produced two doctors, one lawyer, several headmistresses and a college lecturer in Physics.  Many of her grandchildren recall hearing her tell them Bengali folk tales as well as stories from other lands.  Mathura died in Kushtia in 1946.
Manmatha, the eldest son, was born in 1910, when his father was serving as a police officer at Feni, Noakhali.  He matriculated from Rajbari School in 1926 and gained his ISc from Rajendra College in Faridpore and was admitted to Presidency College, Calcutta.  He graduated in 1930 with honours in chemistry.  While studying in Calcutta, he stayed in the Hindu Hostel of the Presidency College.  Academically outstanding, he read widely and took an active interest in a whole range of sports, gaining Calcutta University blues in hockey, football and boxing; his boxing trainer was Mr Van Inghen.  Manmatha read Vishnu De, Jibanananda Das and had a great liking for the works of Manik Bandyopadhyaya.  Throughout his life he kept up his interest in sports, Bengali literature and Left politics.  The politics led him, as it did many others at the time, to seek out and address social problems.
After Presidency College, Manmatha went on to study medicine at Carmichael Medical College (now R G Kar Medical College), Calcutta.  He graduated in 1935, standing first in surgery and awarded the Lt Colonel S P Sarbadhikari Gold Medal.  While in his penultimate year, he joined a voluntary group of doctors, commissioned by the army, who were rushed to Bihar to attend to the victims of the great earthquake centred around Munger that occurred on 15 January 1934.  Completely destroying Munger and Muzaffarpur, this earthquake affected large parts of Bihar and Nepal, taking the death toll to over thirty thousand.  Young Nandy along with the team of volunteers spent over three months working tirelessly in treating rescued people. Years later he told his children that it was the sight of such devastation that made his hair stand up – and it stayed that way!  There was also a touching postscript in the mid-fifties in Dhaka: the family was visited by a young man named Manmatha, who claimed to have been saved from the debris of a collapsing house in Mungerr by Dr Nandy.
Manmatha married Santi Ballow Majumdar in 1934, when she was preparing for her matriculation examination from a boarding school in Jalpaiguri. Her family, though then based in Matelli, a small tea plantation town in the Dooars, was also from Manikganj, not far from Kushtia.  After marriage she carried on her further studies at Scottish Church College.  The couple lived in a flat in the Entally area of Calcutta.  Having qualified as a doctor, Manmatha became a house surgeon and later a registrar at the Carmichael College.  While still a student, he had come to the attention of Dr Bidhan Chandra Roy, the legendary physician and first Chief Minister of West Bengal post-Independence.
In 1939, the very prosperous and charitable family of the Bhagyakul Kundus (the Roys) asked Dr B C Roy to suggest to them a good doctor who would be prepared to help with organising a village hospital in Sreenagar, Bikrampore, Dhaka District.  At Dr Roy’s suggestion, the Kundus approached Dr Nandy.
Manmatha had a bright future ahead of him.  His father-in-law had offered to help financially to send him to England for further studies. Calcutta was a city with plenty of opportunities and plenty of facilities.  Sreenagar had no running water, no electricity, no roads.  The source of drinking water was shallow wells or river water collected mid-stream.  Hurricane lamps and Tilley lamps were the main sources of lighting.  Wireless sets worked off car batteries, which needed to be transported to Dhaka for charging.  Transport was by petrol driven boats and launches in the rainy season or by bicycle along high ground (saraks) at other times. There were no medical facilities nearby.  These were some of the problems; more would become obvious later.  But the wish to give his services to the needy persuaded Dr Nandy to accept the proposition of the Kundus.  In 1939 he decided to take charge of the organisation of the hospital in Sreenagar named after Raja Srinath Roy. Santi, at this time, had given birth to a set of premature twins, a girl and a boy, in Calcutta. It was with his small family that Dr Nandy went to Sreenagar.
The first social problem he faced involved the local Zamindar, an upper caste Hindu, who resented the setting up of a hospital paid for by the Roys (Kundus) known to be Telis by caste. Many obstacles were created by the Zamindar and false allegations were levelled against the young doctor.  The Nandy family have many tales to tell about the petty harassments. Dr Nandy overcame all the troubles that were thrown at him and the Raja Srinath Hospital began to function. In this task Dr Nandy was ably assisted by Dr Monindra Choudhury and Dr Barun Ganguly, who also sacrificed their certain good futures to serve the needy.  The hospital provided its services free and the financial responsibilities were borne by the Bhagyakul family. Later the Zamindar family also came to grow very close to the Nandy family with past problems forgotten and forgiven.
In Sreenagar, another son and daughter completed the family by 1942.  A cow and well helped household hardly eased the family’s austere domestic arrangements. The family acquired a boat with one Majhi (boatman); it was a convertible in the sense that in the rainy season it donned a chhai (covering). The boys were admitted to Sholaghar High School where they travelled mostly on this boat.
During this time Nandy organised football tournaments, a Bikrampore-wide sports event, a library named the Friends Association and a back garden badminton court.  Dr Nandy had earned many medals for his own sports activities which he donated to deserving sportsmen.  Although not playing football himself, he refereed many games.
Many tales are told about the operations Dr Nandy carried out successfully in dimly lit rooms assisted sometimes even by his wife, Santi.  He travelled by boat and/or bicycle to the remotest of places where his diagnostic skills and healing powers came to be reputed as near miraculous.  Many times he escaped from snakes and the hands of dacoits in the course of his duties.  With the assistance of other doctors, he undertook the training of nurses, compounders, hospital cleaners and other paramedical officers.  They had no official diplomas, but they were fit for purpose.
Although the doctor was not an official member of the Communist Party, he was an ardent fellow traveller. With the Party he agreed to the right of self-determination of Muslims. When he came to work in Sreenagar two young Muslim friends came to form lifelong bonds with the family. At the time they were both leftists, but over their lifetime they grew to follow completely different trajectories. Shamsuddin Ahmad, known to the Nandy children as Shamsuddin Kaku, later became a dedicated member of the Muslim League, once officiating as the Secretary. The other friend was the very young Faiz Ahmed whom the children, and in turn their children, called Faiz Da. Both these family members are dead now. Shamsuddin died in Pakistan where he had gone after the Bangladesh war of independence. Faiz Ahmed became famous for his Bengali poetry, political writings and journalism.
In 1943, when Dr Nandy was only 33 years old, Bengal witnessed the worst sub-continental famine in the twentieth century. It was a man-made disaster. In mid-1942, the British government under Winston Churchill feared that the Japanese would follow up their conquest of Burma with an invasion of British India from the Bengal Border. A ‘scorched earth’ policy was implemented in the Chittagong region, near the Burmese border, to prevent access to supplies by the Japanese in case of an invasion. Country boats, the main means of transport of people and foodgrains were systematically disabled and sunk under the ‘Boat Denial Scheme’. Rice stored in godowns was confiscated and food deliveries from other parts of the country to Bengal were refused by the government in order to make food artificially scarce under the ‘Rice Denial Scheme’. Valuable goods and most of the revenue collected were despatched home. Munshiganj, Sreenagar and all of Bikrampur suffered catastrophically. Later, estimates of deaths from this famine reached over four million.
At the time of this famine, Sri Asoke Mitra, ICS, was the sub-divisional officer headquartered in Munshiganj. Dr Nandy and Asoke Mitra co-opted a team and started relief work. Later Mitra recollected his memories of those days in his autobiography ‘Teen Kuri Das’, referring to Doctor Nandy as his friend, philosopher and guide. Dr. Nandy organised the godowns that were emptied of grains, set up temporary hospitals, medical clinics, relief centres and an orphanage. He trained volunteers and received help from St John’s Ambulance. The orphanage was supervised by our mother Santi helped by other volunteers. It is rumoured that both Asoke Mitra and Nandy slept on their bikes. The extreme bicycling took its toll in later years. Nandy and Mitra brought out a small report on the famished mothers of the area. Unfortunately no copies survive.
After the famine, Governor Richard G Casey awarded Dr Nandy a silver medal for his work during this time. Dr Nandy’s work was also mentioned in the Famine Inquiry Commission Report (1945).
In 1946, dark fearful clouds of partition loomed on the Indian horizon. Bengal was to be partitioned as it had been once before. Panic gripped the Hindu upper caste communities in areas that were to become East Pakistan, most of whom decided to migrate to West Bengal. In East Bengal, teachers, doctors, civil servants, lawyers, were mostly upper caste Hindus. Almost all of them abandoned their posts leaving East Pakistan without an adequate social infrastructure for schools, hospitals, law courts and various posts in the civil service. Mathura Nath Nandy had died just before independence. Manmatha would not abandon his Janmabhumi. Thus, he, along with his family, stayed on and accepted citizenship of Pakistan.
In 1948, Dr Nandy was transferred to Dhaka Medical College. Santi had temporarily gone back to her parents with her children to finish her graduation. She came back to finish degrees of Bachelor of Teaching (BT) and Master of Education (MEd) in Dhaka. She served as a headmistress in a number of Government and private schools in Dhaka and Mymensingh. At this time Dr Nandy rented a house – 16, Juginagar, near Thatari Bazaar (now known as Captain’s Bazaar) in Dhaka. The two sons joined the Priyonath School (now known as Nawabpur Boys’ High School) and  the daughters joined the Nari Shiksha Mandir (now called Sher-e-Bangla Nagar Government Girls College), where Santi was the headmistress.

WB lends $500m to help 4m poorest households

The government yesterday signed an agreement with the World Bank to receive $500 million to strengthen the major safety net programmes covering four million of the poorest households.
The fund will support the Safety Net Systems for the Poorest (SNSP) project to be implemented by the disaster management and relief ministry, said a press release.
Abul Kalam Azad, secretary to Economic Relations Division (ERD), Ministry of Finance, and Christine E Kimes, acting head of the World Bank, Bangladesh country office, signed the agreement at the ERD in the capital.
“SNSP would cover the poorest and most marginalised people of the country and thus would directly contribute to the World Bank’s goal of eliminating extreme poverty by 2030 and enhancing shared prosperity,” said Christine Kimes.
It will support improvements in the implementation of the safety net programmes by focusing on the increased allocation of programme resources to benefit the poorest population, strengthening their management and monitoring capacity, and enhancing governance and accountability.
The credit from the International Development Association (IDA), the World Bank’s concessional lending arm, has 40 years to maturity, including a 10-year grace period, and carries a service charge of 0.75 percent, according to the release.
“The government of Bangladesh is committed to poverty reduction and strengthening the coordination, targeting and coverage of social protection programmes,” said ERD Secretary Abul Kalam Azad. “The project is a critical milestone in this process.”
The project will provide technical assistance to the Statistics and Informatics Division for the development of the Bangladesh Poverty Database, which would reduce the overall costs and errors associated with targeting of safety net programmes in the country and facilitate coordination among different ministries responsible for their implementation.
SNSP applies a results-based financing modality whereby 86 percent of the IDA financing would be disbursed on achieving targets such as improved beneficiary selection, the use of modern management information systems, and improved field level implementation with an increased emphasis on addressing beneficiary grievances.

Re-visioning Dhaka

Can Dhaka be saved? Can it be made livable again, and turned into the green and friendly city it once was? Can its crazy landscape of high-rise ghettos, random shopping centres, festering slums and residential neighbourhoods that have also morphed as business districts and commercial hubs be ever redrawn to reflect a proper urban environment? Or, for that matter, can its decaying public places and decrepit parks overrun by squatters, drug dealers and vendors of various dispositions be ever reclaimed and restored to their primary functions? Or its dysfunctional traffic system given a shot in the arm and made to run the way it runs in cities of comparable size, population or importance?
No one should be surprised if the answer to the above questions is a resounding ‘no’ – such is the pessimism that Dhaka’s urban reality breeds, which even grips city planners and administrators. To be fair to them, they have done their part: their have been many projects and plans to revive the city and give it some semblance of order and coherent environment, but none of these plans even reached the stage of implementation.
Dhaka has long reached the limits of ecology and morphology; it has missed all the buses to modernisation. It is a city in perpetual crisis – it has no zoning law, no public transport system, no solid waste management or pollution control strategies, no density distribution, no properly functioning public utility system, , no neighbourhood parks or playing fields or empty spaces, not much of social security and hardly any provision for open air cultural activities. It is plagued by overcrowding which has been triggered by Dhaka’s pre-eminent omniscientrality as successive governments and the corporate sector have placed all their head offices in Dhaka. Dhaka has little respect for its archives. Except for the street lines, most of Dhaka is in a state of flux. It doesn’t allow its citizens to nurture memories. It is a city that takes pride in concentration and city centre living; it is paranoid about connecting with peripheries
Dhaka’s social ecology is a mess; it hardly inspires a concept of place.
Dhaka has never been able to optimize its size or its population; or zone out its schoolsand other non-residential elements.
Dhaka, a riverfront city, has no connection with water. Reclaimed waterbodies fall victim to encroachment and earth filling and eventually disappear.In a recent survey conducted by the London-based Economist Intelligent unit Dhaka scored poorly in almost all the vital indices that define a livable city. It has a public transport system which is hugely dysfunctional as it solely depends on roads. Its infrastructure facilities are poor; its supply of utilities inadequate and its crime rate alarming. Nothing short of a revolution can save the city and effectively put an end to the contradictions and ambiguities that beset it now. That revolution has to draw a new cognitive map of the city, a visionary design that will inspire policy planners, government functionaries, politicians, activists and private entrepreneurs to put their resources together to halt Dhaka’s slide to disaster.
Kazi Khaleed Ashraf’s Designing Dhaka: A Manifesto for a Better City which came out in 2012 offers such a stimulating and challenging design for Dhaka. It proposes a manifesto to bring healing to Dhaka, and solve its problems from the bottom up. He calls Dhaka ‘a stubborn city,’ ‘a city of brutal facts’ balancing itself unsteadily on six different morphologies that define its urban fabric: the settlement along the Buriganga; the colonial spread of the city carving out a ‘new Dhaka,’ the post-1947 development of the city including its planned residential areas, the chaotic and unplanned growth of a jumble of infrastructure that stifled the planned city and the ubiquitous squatter colonies and slums define the city and give it its uniqueness. He picks up the essential properties of each morphology—which he sees as both a reality as well as a promise– and collates them for an understanding of their essential character. What they have in common is a socio-spatial dialectic – more than physical structures – that should not be lost sight of in planning for cohesion and transcendence. ‘A new Dhaka is possible,’ he writes; ‘It can truly be a modern city that is socially, economically and ecologically sustainable.’ And then explains his grounds of optimism. ‘Working with its geography and hydrology, and its growing urban needs,’ he maintains, ‘Dhaka can still be a very unique, green and highly livable city.’
Such an assumption rests on unsure grounds if it is not supported by two essential qualities of a city designer – ‘daring’ and ‘vision.’ Ashraf has both. In the subsequent pages of the book he explains what ‘daring’ implies and what design can do if it assumes a visionary dimension.
Dhaka has a theory part and an action part. The theory part deals with an understanding of spatial ontology, the heterogeneous spaces and their relations, and explains the reasons behind Dhaka’s cataclysmic urban growth. It also defines the city in civilizational terms, explaining how Dhaka, like all comparable cities, has become over the centuries ‘an instrument of destiny.’ Ashraf maintains that a city like Dhaka is an ‘aggregate of economic and technical vectors’ that policy makers and planners should take into account, but it is ‘lived experience’ that should take precedence. He indeed builds on the lived experience to formulate his vision. This is one reason why history is so important to him. In course of his journey through the history of the city he discovers when and where the feeling of place and civitas – civic enterprise – was lost and can be regained.
Another strong point Ashraf makes is that any design for Dhaka has to base itself on ‘a liquid landscape’ and how the plan has to be around land and water, without putting them in an antagonistic position.
The theory part of Designing Dhaka lays the ground of what cultural geographers describe as a ‘critical-mass potential for innovation’ and looks at space as culturally constructed instead of being a given. For a space-starved city like Dhaka, space has to be both material and representational. It has to be a triad of historicality, sociality and spatiality that constitutes human being. The theory part also alerts us to the need of emphasizing more on practices, strategies and interactions rather than on systems and structures.
The action part of Designing Dhaka begins with a 15 point manifesto for making a new Dhaka possible. Briefly stated, these are: urbanism, hydrology, peripheries, the city as an island, containing the city, mobility, housing, open spaces, pedestrian friendly streets, city governance, urban assets, new economy, energy and ecology, catalytic architecture and city of play. Each point is explained and supported by a wealth of information and a doable agenda. In planning the city, Ashraf maintains, urbanism, rather than urbanisation should be the focus, since ‘urbanism is a visualisation of the soul of the city.’ What he emphasizes is an evolutionary philosophy, a ‘meditation on totality’ which would take into account the past, the present and the future. If such a holistic approach is taken and sustained, it would be possible for designers to understand the essential chemistry of land and water and combine them to create a fluid city. A holistic approach should also take the designers from the core of the city to the edge in order to make a polycentric Dhaka and enclose the river within its living parameters.
Kazi Khaleed Ashraf’s manifesto looks at Dhaka as a site where an urban revolution is possible. As architect Saif Ul Haque, another crusader for a new and better Dhaka, remarks in his prologue, ‘All the tasks listed above are not of very complex nature, neither are they very difficult to implement but the question is how much are we willing to do it?’ He then asks, ‘And when do we begin?

Kamalapur railway staff killed

Unidentified miscreants made away with over Tk 17 lakh from the cash of Kamalapur Railway Station in the capital killing one of its staffs Saturday morning.Deceased Mohammad Israfil Hossain, 59, was an assistant of booking section at the railway station, Abdul Majid, officer-in-charge of Dhaka Railway Police Station, told The Daily Star.Hossain, who was hailed from Manikganj, was used to work at the railway on contractual basis.He was serving as the in-charge of cash section in the last night, said Khairul Bashir, station manger of Kamalapur Railway Station.Railway police recovered the body with its hands and legs tied with adhesive tape and neck with a towel from the store room of the railway station around 6:00am, said the OC.Police suspected that Ismail was strangled to death following an internal feud with his colleagues as the store room, where the body found, is restricted for outsiders.Miscreants took Tk 17 lakh and 18 thousand from the railway cash box after killing Hossain between 10:00pm Friday and 6:00am Saturday, said Rafiqul Islam, second officer of the police station.After the killing, Railway Minister Mujibul Haque visited the spot and formed a three-member probe committee to investigate into the incident.The body was sent to Dhaka Medical College and Hospital morgue for autopsy, said Md Zahidul Islam, an assistant sub-inspector of Dhaka Railway Police Station.The incident however did not have an effect on the people who flocked to the station for tickets ahead of the biggest religious festival of Hindus, Durga Puja, and Eid-ul-Azha, the second largest religious festival of Muslims, reports private television channel Somoy TV.

Rampal foundation plaque unveiled

Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and her Indian counterpart Manmohan Singh jointly unveiled the foundation plaque of the coal-based Rampal power plant this morning disregarding environmentalists’ fear of a disastrous impact on the Sundarbans, the world’s largest mangrove forest.Manmohan joined Hasina through video conferencing to uncover the plaque at Bheramara in Kushtia though the power plant site is located at Rampal in Bagerhat, 14 kilometres away from the Sundarbans.The Bheramara site was chosen as the two premiers formally inaugurated the commercial start of electricity import from India at the Bangladesh-India Power Transmission Centre.Bangladesh and India had inked a deal on April 20 to set up the 1,320MW coal-fired power plant, a project that drew flak from environmentalists and eminent citizens, who believe it will jeopardise the Sundarbans.To oppose and demand scrapping of the project, hundreds of people marched from Dhaka to the Rampal project site in last week of September.The demonstration seems to have failed to move the authorities.During his speech Saturday, Manmohan called upon the Bangladesh authorities to maintain environmental standards while constructing the plant saying that the Sundarbans is the common heritage of the two neighbouring countries.Originally, Hasina was scheduled to lay the foundation stone of the Rampal plant on October 22 and Manmohan was supposed to join through video conferencing. The schedule was changed as the Indian premier expressed inability to join the programme that day.About importing power from India, Manmohan said Saturday the transmission line in Bheramara provides a safe and reliable interconnection of the power grids of the two countries which will be able to supply 500MW of power from India to Bangladesh.The Indian premier termed the power export as “a shared aspiration of both the countrymen” which has been “translated into a concrete outcome”.The India-Bangladesh grid interconnection would not only link the grid but also would strengthen the bonds of the friendship between the two countries, he said.“The initiatives being undertaken today strengthen the bonds of friendship between India and Bangladesh and add a rich dimension to our bilateral relation.“Today’s inauguration represents an important milestone in connecting our two countries and the broader region through a growing wave of cross-border energy links and trade,” he added.Prior to the inauguration, Hasina also said that the initiative of sharing power would help strengthen the relationship between the two countries.“Such co-operation would pave the way to embark on more ambitious project to the benefit of both the countries,” she said.“The inter-grid connectivity is a part of immediate solution which would go a long way to alleviate the power deficit Bangladesh,” Hasina noted.Under the 2010 agreement, India will export 500MW of electricity everyday to Bangladesh for 35 years from a substation at Baharampur in West Bengal.A 125-kilometre transmission line, 40km of it in Bangladesh, connects the two substations.India began the test supply with 50MW electricity on September 27. From Saturday, it went up to 250MW every day and will reach 500MW in end-November.

Bangladesh medical camp serving Rohingyas refugees in no-man’s land

Border Guard Bangladesh has set up a medical camp to extend support to the thousands of Rohingya refugees fleeing persecution in Myanmar, ...